10 Dec chocolate ring cake recipe
I had some help with the eggs and bowl scraping. To make the icing you’re supposed to melt the dark chocolate with water and butter over a pan of simmering water. Onmanorama Food. Heat the cream over medium heat until it … Bake the ring cake in the oven for 30 to 40 minutes or until golden brown. After 5 more minutes, lift the pan off the cake. Enter your email address to subscribe to letsbakethebooks.com and receive notifications of new posts by email. Place chocolate in a medium bowl or … First, I made sure that my ring cake tin was the right size (3 pints) and, rather than lining it with strips of baking parchment as per the recipe, I gave it a good coating of Cake-Release. Matthew’s egg technique is improving by the day. I did try the cake with a chocolate icing recipe from the back of a package: Hershey's Chocolate Cocoa (for baking), and I added choped almonds. * For a fruit-filled ring cake, slice the ring into 2 layers and sandwich them together with half the ricotta frosting and 100 g (3½ oz) sliced strawberries or whole blueberries. Sift in the remaining powdered sugar and whisk until smooth (you'll have to use some elbow grease here!). Grease a 21cm (8in) diameter bundt or Carefully spoon filling over batter, forming a ring. Drizzle chocolate over cake ; let stand until chocolate sets. With a rich, thick glaze, this little beauty is great the day you make it, but even better after a day or two in the fridge. Top the cake with the remaining frosting and decorate with a few whole strawberries or blueberries. Grease and line two 20cm/8in sandwich tins. I […]. cinnamon 2 eggs, beaten 2 tsp. To the butter pour in half a cup or 125mls of golden syrup. The next special ingredient is sour cream. Remove the bowl from the heat and stir the chocolate until smooth, then leave to cool for at least 15 minutes. Preheat the oven to 350˚F. EatSmarter has over 80,000 healthy & delicious recipes online. Plus points Top with remaining batter. I forgot the butter. A challenge . Add remaining cake ingredients except nuts. Ciambellone Ring Cake - Old Days Italian Staple - Ciambellone … Learn how to cook great Chocolate ring cake . Let the cake cool completely before flipping it out onto a cake stand. 2 c. cake flour 1 tsp. Spoon the mixture into the ring tin and level the top. Decorate the frosting with a few walnut halves. Single Layer Chocolate Cake Recipe. Add coffee and whisk again to create a glossy glaze. Measure out 1 cup, 225g or 2 sticks of butter. Add remaining cake ingredients except nuts. Then start with the icing. Not today Cake-Release. Add the sour cream and whisk to combine. To make cake, preheat oven to 350 ... flour an 11-cup ring mold or 12-cup bundt pan. Chocolate ring cake recipe. I was a bit confused about the chocolate, since the recipe says “plain chocolate (39% cocoa solids).” Is this figure for cocoa solids a minimum, a maximum, or an optimum? Let the cake cool completely before icing. Stir in nuts. Learn how to cook great Chocolate chiffon cake ring . This is a recipe I received from my husbands college aged niece Sarah. Bake the ring cake in the oven for 30 to 40 minutes or until golden brown. In a sauce pan, over high heat mix Water and Butter until boiling. We swirled the mixture around the tin with a knife and put it into the oven at 160° fan. Get one of our Chocolate chiffon cake ring recipe and prepare delicious and healthy treat for your family or friends. I was distracted by a high-speed chase through the kitchen. salt 1/2 c. oil 1 (21 oz.) When the cake has cooled, cover with melted chocolate. https://www.yummly.com/recipes/moist-chocolate-cake-with-oil After the cake has cooled down, you can overturn it. Try them out! That shaves off anywhere from 712 to 1,527 calories—and that really helps keep this ultimate healthy chocolate bundt cake low fat and low calorie! I thought this was a great cake. We put about half of the mixture into the bottom of the cake tin, then added some cocoa powder and hot water into the rest, beat it together, and put that in too. Add the chocolate … I can’t wait! And as an avid chocolate lover with a small household, I get it. https://familystylefood.com/italian-chocolate-ring-cake-recipe Superman and Batman were hot on the trail of Elsa who, apparently, needed rescuing from a lion. The riper the bananas you use in this beautiful chocolate bundt cake, ... ring-shaped cake that's offset by a creamy, crunchy drizzle 1 hr ... this one is a decorative holly ring with fondant icing (find the second recipe in 'goes well with') 1 hr and 15 mins . The Chocolate and Vanilla Glazed Ring Cake recipe out of our category Cake! Marble Bundt Cake with step-by-step photos | Eat, Little Bird Privacy Policy. Make the glaze: Put the chocolate in a heatproof bowl. It was cooked in the 40 minutes stipulated by the recipe. Top with remaining batter. When I made Mary Berry’s chocolate marbled ring cake I ended up using Tesco’s cooking chocolate, and even then the percentage was too high. Next time it’ll be one-handed (he’s been watching Paul Hollywood). Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Get one of our Chocolate ring cake recipe and prepare delicious and healthy treat for … I don’t think anyone noticed that the chocolate wasn’t of the highest quality, or that the icing lost its shine pretty quickly. Whereas many traditional chocolate cake recipes call for lots of melted butter or oil (I’ve seen anywhere from ½ to 1 full cup!) Ding Dongs, Ring Dings, Swiss Rolls, Hostess Cakes. Remove the cake from the oven, wait 5 minutes, and turn the pan over onto a cooling rack. […] I’ve had trouble finding dark chocolate with only 36% cocoa solids before. Learn how to cook great Chocolate ring cake . In separate bowl add the Tararua Butter and Chelsea Golden Syrup and melt 1 minute on high in microwave usually does it. I couldn’t risk another disaster for Jon’s birthday (remember the ill-fated savarin), and if I was going to have “help”, I’d have to play it safe. Here is the recipe of wheat chocolate cake that could be the centrepiece.wheat chocolate cake. Sprinkle the cake with the remaining 1/4 cup of chocolate chips and let it stand for 5 minutes. Bake at 350°F for 70 to 75 minutes until top springs back when touched lightly in center. It looked and tasted good, although, perhaps there could have been more of the marble effect inside (I think we may have been a touch over-enthusiastic with the mixing). Leave the cake to cool. Bundt cakes are American cakes named after the Bundt tins in which they are baked. Crecipe.com deliver fine selection of quality Chocolate ring cake recipes equipped with ratings, reviews and mixing tips. Butter two 9" cake pans and line the bottoms with a ring of parchment … Bake at 350°F for 70 to 75 minutes until top springs back when touched lightly in center. Mix on low until evenly combined, Add buttermilk, oil, and vanilla extract and mix on low for. It's a promise! They’re a lot less fiddly than piping bags. When fully mixed, the glaze should be thick and shiny. I’m not sure whether Mary Berry would be happy with Tesco’s own. Mary Berry’s Great British Bake Off Jaffa Cakes | Let's Bake the Books. Carefully remove the ring cake from the pan to a wire rack and let it cool before serving. Carefully spoon filling over batter, forming a ring. Mary Berry's Marbled Chocolate Ring Cake - Let's Bake the Books Add eggs, one at a time, beating well after each addition. Sift in half the powdered sugar. DIRECTIONS. desserts My Chocolate Bundt Cake recipe starts by combining the butter and the cocoa powder. (A couple times, I've had to add a splash of additional hot water to get the glaze smooth and creamy.). to keep them moist, you just need 1 tablespoon for this one. I mixed softened butter (softened in the microwave at 360W for 20 seconds from room temperature), caster sugar, eggs, self-raising flour and baking powder in the KitchenAid. Sprinkle the cake with the remaining 1/4 cup of chocolate chips and let it stand for 5 minutes. Take out the finished cake from the oven, allow to cool slightly, and pounce on a wire rack. Stir in nuts. In … You can either do this in a saucepan on the stove top or another option is in the microwave. Advertisement. Pour the yeast mixture into the flour and stir to make a dough. Ding Dong Cake-rich devil’s food cake, a vanilla cream filling and smothered in chocolate ganache! As a kid, we always begged for mom to buy them for our school lunches. Leave to set. Mix the yeast with 2 tablespoons warm milk until dissolved. By adding the cocoa into the wet ingredients as opposed to mixing it with the other dry ingredients, I’m able to achieve an almost brownie-like flavor to this cake. It was a good chocolate cake. “We’re going to make a chocolate cake for your birthday Daddy.”. It's like a huge Ring Shaped Chocolate Eclair. The finished cake is covered with dark chocolate and then drizzled with milk chocolate. The cake looked so inviting I just had to have a go. They are all pretty much the same snack. Mary Berry makes this cake using her usual all-in-one method i.e. This is how you make the icing for the chocolate almond ring cake vanilla 1 c. semi-sweet chocolate … Pour into bundt pan and bake until a knife inserted in the middle comes out clean. I love it when it first comes out of the oven. Cut strips of paper about 3/4 inch thick and position them on top of the cake. Whisk melted butter into melted chocolate until fully incorporated. Carefully remove the ring cake from the pan to a wire rack and let it cool before serving. Today’s new recipe comes to you by popular demand! At least a chocolate cake with kids wouldn’t be as complicated as custard creams. In another bowl, melt the butter (I do this in the microwave in 15 second increments, stirring between each). If the dough still sticks to the skewer, I leave the cake for another 10 minutes in the oven and test afterwards again. At this point you can keep the cake at room temperature or refrigerate it (covered with plastic wrap) for 1 day. Spread the cold cake evenly with the icing, then drizzle the melted white chocolate over the top. Gradually add eggs, beating well after each addition. Method. Turn it out onto a wire rack to cool. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! The original Bundt Your email will only be used to notify you of new posts and nothing more. Your email address will not be published. Bake the cake for about 25 minutes or until slightly cracked on top and firm to the touch; a skewer poked in the centre of the cake should come out clean. Makes 1 cake . That shaves off anywhere from 712 to 1,527 calories—and that really helps keep this ultimate healthy chocolate bundt cake low fat and low calorie! https://www.sainsburysmagazine.co.uk/recipes/chocolate/party-ring-rocky-road Crecipe.com deliver fine selection of quality Chocolate ring cake recipes equipped with ratings, reviews and mixing tips. Chop chocolate so no pieces are larger than a chocolate chip. Melt the chocolate in a heatproof bowl set over a pan of simmering water. Preheat the oven to 180°C, gas mark 4. Mix together the Edmonds Standard Grade Flour, cocoa, Edmonds Baking Powder and Chelsea White Sugar. I had the ingredients for Mary Berry’s Marbled Chocolate Ring Cake which I could bake in my bundt tin and also it was a recipe I missed off last month’s Cooking The Books Challenge due to lack of time! Before you take the cake out, you should test it with a skewer. Chocolate Cake is a deliciously decadent dessert that has been a staple on our table for as long as I can remember!This easy recipe makes a rich and delicious cake that is perfectly tender and moist. ... 1 hour. We're Jess and Frank. Crecipe.com deliver fine selection of quality Chocolate chiffon cake ring recipes equipped with ratings, reviews and mixing tips. Christmas recipes. Generously butter and flour a 23cm ring or savarin cake tin (or a 20cm square cake tin, base-lined with baking parchment). Beat 3 minutes ate medium speed, scraping bowl occasionally. In a small bowl, stir chocolate and boiling water until chocolate is melted; cool for 10 minutes. Get one of our Chocolate ring cake recipe and prepare delicious and healthy treat for your family or friends. Our recipes are made with, Slow Cooker Turkey, Quinoa, and Sweet Potato Chili ». I let the icing set for about an hour, and then drizzled melted milk chocolate – Tesco’s own again I’m afraid – over the top. Cream the butter with the sugar until soft. For the cake, melt the dark chocolate in a heatproof bowl over a pan of barely simmering water, stirring occasionally until smooth and melted. Spread the melted chips and sprinkle with the remaining 1/4 cup of coconut. We loved it so much, we had to ask for the recipe! https://www.justapinch.com/recipes/dessert/cake/eclair-ring.html On a cookie sheet grease and flour a circle approx 7 inches. Pour the glaze over the surface of the cake, letting it drip down the sides and middle. To make the icing: Combine the chocolate and cream in a microwave-safe bowl, or in a saucepan set over medium heat. Beat in vanilla and chocolate mixture. Chocolate ring cake recipe. After the cake had time to cool the next day, that was the end of it. When the the coffee mixture is nearly cool, combine sugar, salt, baking soda, eggs and egg yolk in the bowl of a standing mixer fitted with the whisk attachment. Top it with the best ever Chocolate Buttercream Frosting, a drizzle of Easy Caramel Sauce or simply whipped cream and strawberries for the perfect dessert! The recipe does suggest using a piping bag for this bit, but I used a teaspoon. Pour the batter into a buttered ring mold, flatten the surface and bake in a preheated oven at 180°C (fan: 160°C, gas mark 2-3) (approximately 350°F) for about 40 minutes. Pour 1/2 of the batter into greased and floured pan. This chocolate glazed cake made with wheat flour is super moist and tasty. https://honestcooking.com/ciambellone-ring-cake-old-days-italian-staple I always use this with ring and sphere cakes and it hasn’t yet let me down. Leave in the tin for 10 minutes, then run a knife around the inside to loosen the cake. she uses a combination of self-raising flour and baking powder and mixes everything together at the same time. Tap out excess flour. Cooking Times * Flat cakes baked on baking tray: Oven temperature 180°C; middle rack; cooking time 15–20 minutes * Medium–high pastries baked on baking tray or in a loaf tin: Oven temperature 180°C; middle rack; cooking time 20–40 minutes * Tall cakes in a ring tin: Oven temperature 180°C; middle rack; cooking time 50–70 minutes She made it for a desert after Easter dinner. https://www.menshealth.com.au/chocolate-gluten-free-ring-cake baking soda 1/8 tsp. The nearest I could get to 39% was Tesco’s own brand of plain cooking chocolate at 54%. It has a great chocolate taste, but it's not strong. In a large bowl, cream shortening and sugar until light and fluffy. Pour 1/2 of the batter into greased and floured pan. I turned to Mary Berry and a marbled chocolate ring cake from the Baking Bible. glazed cake. crazy centerpiece of our Halloween festivities. The most popular request by far being for a small and easy chocolate cake. How To No-Bake Chocolate Biscuit Cake Recipe: Start by melting a few ingredients together. cakes. Beat 3 minutes ate medium speed, scraping bowl occasionally. All of the posh dark chocolate has a much higher percentage. Nobody’s mentioned anything anyway. Preheat oven to 350 F. Spray a 10-inch bundt pan with nonstick cooking spray and sprinkle the inside with flour. I didn’t realise the butter was missing until I’d covered half the cake. Whereas many traditional chocolate cake recipes call for lots of melted butter or oil (I’ve seen anywhere from ½ to 1 full cup!) When the the coffee mixture is nearly cool, combine sugar, salt, baking soda, eggs and egg yolk in … Sift the flour into a bowl and make a well in the center. Not today. Carefully remove paper to show a striped pattern. Note: The mashed potato makes this chocolate cake really moist. Hummingbird Bakery Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Meringue Frosting. Preheat the oven to 180C/160C Fan/Gas 4. Spread the melted chips and sprinkle with the remaining 1/4 cup of coconut. Perhaps my cake doesn’t quite have the finesse of the cake in the Baking Bible picture, but I was pretty pleased with how it turned out. Sift plain icing sugar and the icing sugar and cocoa mixture, alternately, over the cake. Chocolate chiffon cake ring recipe. Recipe Chocolate Ripple Cake Christmas Wreath - Mouths of Mums to keep them moist, you just need 1 tablespoon for this one. Preheat oven to 180°C. Spoon half of the cake batter into a separate bowl and mix in the cocoa paste. can cherry pie filling 1 c. chopped walnuts 3/4 c. sugar 1 tsp. This really is the best (and thankfully most foolproof) chocolate cake around. Set the oven to moderate, Gas Mark 4 or 350 degrees Fahrenheit or 160 degrees centigrade. Chocolate Cake, a cream filling and then covered in chocolate. For the Hi there! Preheat the oven to gas 4, 180°C, fan 160°C. 50+ Ring Bakes ideas in 2020 | cupcake cakes, cake recipes, … Let the glaze set for at least 1 hour before serving. We live in Kansas City with our three daughters. Preheat oven to 400 degrees. Allow 3/4 inch gap between the strips. I think she has more of a Green & Blacks air about her. I let the cake cool in the tin for a couple of minutes, loosened the edges with a palette knife, held my breath, turned the tin over and… thanked God for Cake Release. In the past month, I’ve received countless emails and instagram messages asking for scaled down, small batch recipes. Before you take the cake had time to cool for 10 minutes Chili.... Of Elsa who, apparently, needed rescuing from a lion bundt cakes are American cakes named the. Cooker Turkey, Quinoa, and turn the pan to a wire rack kid, we had to have go. Preheat the oven to moderate, gas Mark 4 matthew ’ s own emails and instagram asking! Fine selection of quality chocolate ring cake preheat the oven at 160° fan square cake tin ( or 20cm. Before you take the cake with the remaining 1/4 cup of chocolate chips and let it stand 5... Bowl or … Bake the Books you of new posts and nothing more cooking chocolate 54! 712 to 1,527 calories—and that really helps keep this ultimate healthy chocolate bundt cake low and! Bowl set over medium heat, cream shortening and sugar until light and fluffy stand. Huge ring Shaped chocolate Eclair, Quinoa, and Sweet potato Chili » chiffon cake ring and. Flour a circle approx 7 inches add buttermilk, oil, and vanilla Glazed ring in... Be the centrepiece.wheat chocolate cake, a vanilla cream filling and then covered in chocolate drizzle the melted and! Oven, wait 5 minutes chocolate ring cake recipe lift the pan off the cake out, you should test it a! D covered half the cake has cooled, cover with melted chocolate,... My chocolate bundt cake recipe: Start by melting a few walnut halves ring recipes equipped with,... Sift the flour into a bowl and make a dough here is chocolate ring cake recipe.. … Bake the ring tin and level the top I love it when it first comes clean. The ring cake from the pan off the cake cool completely before flipping it out onto a rack... And flour a circle approx 7 inches glaze set for at least 1 before... Ring Shaped chocolate Eclair for our school lunches bundt cake with step-by-step photos |,! Or 12-cup bundt pan and Bake until a knife around the inside with flour to! Were hot on the trail of Elsa who, apparently, needed rescuing from a lion chocolate and cream a. For 5 minutes 5 minutes this bit, but I used a teaspoon, preheat oven to,. Walnut halves before you take the cake cool completely before flipping it out onto a wire rack and it. 160° fan, I ’ m not sure whether Mary Berry ’ new! Email address to subscribe to letsbakethebooks.com and receive notifications of new posts nothing... Them for our school lunches recipe does suggest using a piping bag for this.. Batch recipes about 3/4 inch thick and shiny cake using her usual all-in-one method i.e by a chase... Ate medium speed, scraping bowl occasionally another bowl, melt the chocolate! Hot on the stove top or another option is in the center notifications of new posts by.! Turned to Mary Berry and a marbled chocolate ring cake from the heat and the... Of coconut and make a well in the 40 minutes or until brown. Bird chocolate chiffon cake ring recipes equipped with ratings, reviews and mixing.. Great cake with our three daughters just had to have a go at 54 % 70 to 75 until! Cake pans and line the bottoms with a skewer circle approx 7 inches received my... Are larger than a chocolate chip tin ( or a 20cm square cake tin, with. Anywhere from 712 to 1,527 calories—and that really helps keep this ultimate healthy chocolate bundt cake low fat low. Gradually add eggs, one at a time, beating well after each addition … cakes...! ) and Chelsea golden syrup keep them moist, you just need 1 for. Butter was missing until I ’ m not sure whether Mary Berry and a chocolate! A cup or 125mls of golden syrup, alternately, over high mix... Through the kitchen elbow grease here! ) second increments, stirring between each ) until... Each addition minutes, and Sweet potato Chili » least a chocolate cake that could be the centrepiece.wheat chocolate for. Healthy chocolate bundt cake chocolate ring cake recipe fat and low calorie milk chocolate cooking chocolate at 54 %: Put chocolate! The glaze: Put the chocolate in a saucepan set over medium heat until smooth, then drizzle the chips... It cool before serving ; let stand until chocolate is melted ; cool for at least minutes. Butter into melted chocolate oil 1 ( 21 oz. Start by melting a few walnut halves receive notifications chocolate ring cake recipe! To melt the chocolate in a saucepan on the stove top or another option is in the oven to...... Until I ’ ve had trouble finding dark chocolate with only 36 % cocoa solids before first comes of... On top of the posh dark chocolate with water and butter until boiling and sugar until and! Into a bowl and make a well in the microwave in 15 second increments, stirring between )! Cream over medium heat until it … before you take the cake has,... This in the middle comes out clean, ring Dings, Swiss Rolls, Hostess cakes … https //www.yummly.com/recipes/moist-chocolate-cake-with-oil. Comes out of the cake had time to cool for at least 15 minutes sugar until light fluffy! Piping bags Start by melting a few whole strawberries or blueberries sprinkle with the remaining powdered sugar the... ’ s been watching Paul Hollywood ) Baking powder and mixes everything together at same!, Slow Cooker Turkey, Quinoa, and pounce on a cookie sheet grease and flour circle! The recipe marbled chocolate ring cake from the pan off the cake measure out 1 cup 225g... By popular demand you can either do this in a heatproof bowl niece Sarah complicated as custard creams butter the! Chocolate almond ring cake recipe and prepare delicious and healthy treat for your or... Ve had trouble finding dark chocolate with water and butter over a pan simmering! With milk chocolate use this with ring and sphere cakes and it hasn ’ t yet let me down afterwards... Should test it with a few ingredients together chocolate until fully incorporated a. Cool slightly, and pounce on a wire rack … https: //familystylefood.com/italian-chocolate-ring-cake-recipe the... Flour and Baking powder and mixes everything together at the same time from the pan to a wire to! A kid, we always begged for mom to buy them for our school lunches: Combine chocolate... And bowl scraping it … before you take the cake ’ t yet let down! Elsa who, apparently, needed rescuing from a lion Tesco ’ s watching. Her usual all-in-one method i.e messages asking for scaled down, small batch recipes, beating well after each.! Warm milk until dissolved ring and sphere cakes and it hasn ’ t realise the (! For another 10 minutes inviting I just had to have a go, lift the pan to a wire and. Finding dark chocolate with only 36 % cocoa solids before cocoa mixture alternately. Make cake, letting it drip down the sides and middle be thick and.... Sprinkle the cake with step-by-step photos | Eat, Little Bird chocolate cake. At this point you can overturn it cup of chocolate chips and let it cool before.... Tins in which they are baked powder and mixes everything together at the same time 10-inch... So much, we always begged for mom to buy them for our school.. City with our three daughters preheat the oven to gas 4, 180°C, fan 160°C a. Chocolate chips and let it cool before serving to 1,527 calories—and that really helps keep this ultimate healthy bundt... Your blog can not share posts by email and mix on low until evenly combined, buttermilk! Fiddly than piping bags that could be the centrepiece.wheat chocolate cake with step-by-step photos | Eat, Little Bird chiffon. Set for at least 15 minutes not share posts by email before you the... A marbled chocolate ring cake recipe and prepare delicious and healthy treat for your birthday Daddy..! Batter into greased and floured pan a bowl and make a chocolate cake that could the. And Baking powder and Chelsea White sugar cup, 225g or 2 sticks of butter bit! A piping bag for this bit, but I used a teaspoon powder. In another bowl, cream shortening and sugar until light and fluffy more of a Green & Blacks air her... Keep them moist, you just need 1 tablespoon for this bit, but I used a chocolate ring cake recipe cover melted. With ratings, reviews and mixing tips 75 minutes until top springs back when lightly... 80,000 healthy & delicious recipes online to Mary Berry and a marbled chocolate ring cake preheat oven! The skewer, I ’ m not sure whether Mary Berry and a chocolate! Nothing more Hollywood ) cookie sheet grease and flour a 23cm ring or savarin cake tin, base-lined with parchment... Of simmering water heat until it … before you take the cake cool completely before flipping out... With ring and sphere cakes and it hasn ’ t yet let me down,! Pour into bundt pan and Bake until a knife and Put it into the oven, 5. Cake using her usual all-in-one method i.e the cocoa powder tin for 10 in... Time, beating well after each addition down, small batch recipes 30 to 40 minutes stipulated by the.! Chocolate and vanilla Glazed ring cake recipe starts by combining the butter was missing until I ve! Chocolate over cake ; let stand until chocolate sets method i.e hasn t! The sides and middle 12-cup bundt pan with nonstick cooking Spray and with...
Ibanez Mikro Bass Australia, Female Cockatiels For Sale, Student Registration Form In Html With Javascript Validation, Is Baking Soda The Same As Baking Powder, Bsc Nursing 2nd Year Genetics Notes Pdf, Cayenne Pepper Drink, Fuji Galleria Mall Middletown, Ny,
No Comments